Book Review – Croydonopolis

Developer and operator Unibail-Rodamco-Westfield (URW) has been granted planning permission by Croydon Council to revitalise the frontage of Croydon’s historic department store Allders with several new food offers, shops and other services.

So reads the latest press release highlighting yet another initiative involving Croydon and its cityscape that has long been entwined with retail. The full story is told in a newly-released book Croydonopolis by Will Noble (published by Safe Haven Books) that details something of a rollercoaster ride for the town that hasn’t quite managed to attain City status – despite its best efforts.

I can recall Christmas drinks on a couple of occasions in the mid-1990s in the board room of Allders with some of the directors along with my colleagues at the time from Retail Week. Our office was just down the road. We’d be extended an invite that we found hard to turn down. The offer of working in Croydon was something that I could have easily turned down because I was living in North London at the time.

Croydon was also less than a top-draw attraction beyond the appeal of the Dog & Bell and Royal Standard pubs. I was not alone in my thinking. In 1996 – about the time I was there – The Independent called it “the high-rise epicentre of all things suburban, bureaucratic and dull…the spiritual home of malls…of superstores, DIY centres and of polyester-nylon suits”.

Rather harsh. Clearly something went wrong as the town’s name is possibly derived from an earlier moniker of Crogedene that translates into Valley of the crocuses. Highlighting the extremes of the perception of Croydon Noble does a great job of telling the story of its rather rich history and home of great innovations as well as being something of a hot-bed for progressive retail activity.

The most notable of these being the Whitgift Shopping Centre that was named after John Whitgift a major character and benefactor in the town from around 1530. Improved infrastructure in the Victorian period led to Croydon having the reachable objective of becoming Surrey’s answer to Oxford Street no less.

Not too far-fetched when you consider that by the late 19th Century it had an array of modern shops including Wilson’s Oriental Café, Remsbury’s Department Store, Japanese Art Stores, and Indian Cigar Stores. Drinks merchant Mr D.H.Weston sold lager for “those people with whom English Ales disagree”.

Noble has a breezy style, weaving humour, history and facts in a very readable manner as he tells the stories of some notable Croydon retail history such as attracting the first suburban Sainsbury’s in 1882, Woolworths in 1912 and Kennard’s Department Store in 1853 that competed with Selfridges as it housed the likes of a Tudor Restaurant and Sundae Bar.

There was something of a department store war waging as Kennard’s sought to outdo Allders, which opened in 1862, and Grants that joined the fray in 1894. But the gung-ho days did not last and by the 1990s Croydon was in one of its dips as it suffered from the opening of nearby Lakeside in 1990 and Bluewater in 1999. The Glades shopping centre in Bromley added to the pressure in 1991.

Allders entered administration in 2012 some 12 years or so after I departed and was followed by the closure of Debenhams in 2020 that had bought Kennard’s and renamed it in 1972.

With the URW deal in the offing maybe we will see another period of renaissance and Croydon will achieve its aim of achieving City status. It was turned down in 2000 and 2002 with the latter a result of the ruling body arguing the town had “no particular identity of its own”.

Although I’ve concentrated on its retail history – for obvious reasons on this platform – Noble does a sterling job of also telling the story of its architecture, music (Fairfield Halls and the Greyhound anyone?), art and impressive countryside and gardens that I’d argue suggests the box tickers deciding City status might have been a tad harsh.

Glynn Davis, editor, Retail Insider

Read More »

Time to prune complexity in garden centres

Garden centres and DIY stores used to be relatively straightforward affairs with demarcation between the rough-edged trade-only propositions and the softer consumer-focused retailers. They also operated predominantly from physical stores and maybe had a paper-based catalogue on the side but it was the same product assortment. Over the years things have become increasingly blurred betweenRead full story

Read full story

Pied à Terre – home of permanently great service

Retailers can learn lots about delivering great personal service from the hospitality industry – here’s a personal tale… When walking down Charlotte Street with my daughter heading for a dinner booking a bright shirt came into view and then a smiling face that I immediately recognised as David Moore sat outside his restaurant Pied àRead full story

Read full story

Retail Insider event with Andy Harding, CEO at NiX by Nicola Harding and MD at NH&Co.

Retail Insider held its latest event with guest speaker Andy Harding, CEO at NiX by Nicola Harding and MD at NH&Co., at Hedonism Wines in London’s Mayfair followed by a tutored tasting of wines. The event sponsored by BetterCommerce involved senior executives from Jigsaw, Ribble Cycles, Henderson Design Group, Heal’s and Stuart Trevor hearing AndyRead full story

Read full story

Breaking out of the legacy cycle

Visiting a renowned brewery in Yorkshire recently involved a tour around its Victorian architecture and equipment that reminded me of the scenario facing many retailers in the UK in ensuring they are not hidebound by legacy infrastructure. The impressive copper brewing vessels date back to the early nineteenth century and are evocative of the eraRead full story

Read full story

Mixing it up at MAPIC

As the days tick down to the major European retail property show, MAPIC, on the South coast of France in Cannes the key themes to be covered have been highlighted at a preview event in London. This year’s exhibitors and speakers will again highlight the ongoing move away from old school retail involving simply floggingRead full story

Read full story

It’s never too early for…Tesco Christmas range preview

Retail Insider this week attended the Tesco Christmas range preview event in East London which, given that the mince pies and chocolate Santas are already in the supermarkets, did not actually feel far too early. As with last year the great thing about this event is that alongside the displays of food and the executiveRead full story

Read full story

Reassessing Direct-to-Consumer model

Dollar Shave Club took the world by storm when its 2012 YouTube video featuring founder Michael Dubin promoting the launch of its unique razor subscription service went mega-viral and kick-started a generation of new DTC (Direct-to-Consumer) businesses. The idea of newly-created brands totally bypassing third-party retailers and going straight to consumers to sell their productsRead full story

Read full story

On the right tracks

In 2007, when I was given a tour around the St Pancras station redevelopment by its co-owner, London & Continental Railways, the place was still very much a work in progress, with builders and heavy machinery scattered across the sprawling site working towards hitting the impending opening deadline. With a hefty 8,000 square metres ofRead full story

Read full story

The threat of ongoing incursions from retailers

Wandering around the reopened Waitrose store in Finchley, north London, on the preview night, it was clear that the food-to-go element had been turbo-charged and the plan is to feed some of the new innovations in this store into the rest of the retailer’s estate. Waitrose joins a growing band of retailers looking to grabRead full story

Read full story