Looping in feedback

Being ghosted is a phenomenon that nobody wants to experience but retailers and hospitality companies are doing exactly that to many thousands of people, which is very damaging to their brands.

This occurs when people are applying for jobs and the candidate invariably hears nothing back. Even when the applicant is massively qualified for the role. The best most people can expect is to initially receive an automated response stating that if they do not hear back within two weeks then they can assume they have not secured the job. Great.

What makes this scenario even worse is that most people will have expected their application to at least been considered but in reality the volume of applications for roles in the retail and hospitality industries is so high that many will not even be viewed. On that basis, even with the best will in the world, providing feedback to all applicants would actually be impossible.

Against this backdrop, the one recommendation recruiters would give to candidates is to apply early because the shortlist will likely have been filled before the application deadline has been reached. Recruitment teams are unlikely to wait for all applications to come in before looking at them I’m reliably informed. It’s a tick for HR teams if they fill a role quickly, irrespective of deadlines.

Clearly feedback would be incredibly valuable – whether that is at the screening stage or after shortlisting and interviews have been concluded. The ideal situation would be for every applicant to receive tailored details on what they could have said differently, what they could have added, how they could have presented themselves differently, and any recommendations for their future applications and interviews.

The reality is that feedback is near-non-existent at the volume, entry-level end of the market and it would be a mistake to believe that things are dramatically different where senior roles are involved. The likely feedback received is that the company loved the candidate but that they lost out to a better candidate and therefore did not get the job.   

Where feedback is given it is most likely to involve the person who got the job. There is a lot of hype at the moment around the candidate experience but normally during these exercises many organisations simply, yet again, only talk to applicants who were successfully appointed. They do not ask for the thoughts of the 99.9% of people who failed to secure the role.

This lack of any feedback and ghosting is particularly damaging to retailers and hospitality companies because the failed applicants are likely to also be customers of the company to which they have applied. It is inconceivable that a company would simply shut down its customer services department and ignore its customers. But the equivalent of this happens with recruitment. Candidates are ignored and at the same time are expected to still spend money with that organisation.

This is wishful thinking because many disgruntled people choose not to frequent the companies who have given them a bad recruiting experience. Taking a look at the likes of Glassdoor and Indeed and they will reveal there are plenty of people vocalising their intent to avoid spending money with certain companies in the future. 

Giving feedback, especially the variety that avoids all elements of contention, is incredibly tough. It is not only very time-consuming for HR and recruiting teams but is also a very delicate matter. Even the ability to fall back on notes taken during interviews can be hard when they are often thin on the ground because during the hectic process note-taking is not a priority.

Technology can play an increasing role in such areas. The ability to conduct an interview using AI tools and for the conversation to result in fully-tailored feedback to each of the candidates – and to the employer too – is within grasp. The ability to deliver an empathetic experience, and maintain a positive view of the brand, to all candidates through the recruitment process is possible with the right technology.

Glynn Davis, editor, Retail Insider

Supported by:

TalentUnlimited

Read More »

The Wonder stuff 

Few of you will likely have heard of Tony Hoggett, who last month announced his departure from the role of head of grocery stores at Amazon. To retail commentators, it was a surprise and suggested the digital behemoth had not really been having the predicted impact on physical food retail, and so Hoggett needed anotherRead full story

Read full story

Scaling the applications mountain

Recruitment continues to suffer from what could be described as an ongoing crisis as technology has made it so easy for candidates to apply for roles that they are swamping employers with unmanageable numbers of applications. One-click routes to applying via online jobs boards has led to a pandemic of incoming applications for retailers andRead full story

Read full story

Carving up the retail sector

It does not look to be the most attractive role in the retail sector but the CEO position at Boohoo is currently the most fought after in the industry. In the blue corner we have Mike Ashley, founder of Frasers Group, who wants to install himself as chief of the online fashion retailer and inRead full story

Read full story

Fathers & Daughters Dine – Mildreds Soho

Many of the vegan and vegetarian restaurant chains that sprang up over recent years have disappeared, having been spatchcocked into closure as they have all too often sought to replicate meat dishes in plant-based form. My daughter is vegetarian and we’ve visited a number of such places with very mixed results. Frequently it has involvedRead full story

Read full story

Right-sizing high street outlets

During a recent meeting at the original Grind coffee shop in London’s Old Street, I was discussing with data specialists CACI how the branded coffee players will have to better manage their historical physical spaces in this digital, work-from-home era when, after exactly one hour, a server with an iPad asked if we would likeRead full story

Read full story

Book Review – Croydonopolis

Developer and operator Unibail-Rodamco-Westfield (URW) has been granted planning permission by Croydon Council to revitalise the frontage of Croydon’s historic department store Allders with several new food offers, shops and other services. So reads the latest press release highlighting yet another initiative involving Croydon and its cityscape that has long been entwined with retail. TheRead full story

Read full story

Time to prune complexity in garden centres

Garden centres and DIY stores used to be relatively straightforward affairs with demarcation between the rough-edged trade-only propositions and the softer consumer-focused retailers. They also operated predominantly from physical stores and maybe had a paper-based catalogue on the side but it was the same product assortment. Over the years things have become increasingly blurred betweenRead full story

Read full story

Pied à Terre – home of permanently great service

Retailers can learn lots about delivering great personal service from the hospitality industry – here’s a personal tale… When walking down Charlotte Street with my daughter heading for a dinner booking a bright shirt came into view and then a smiling face that I immediately recognised as David Moore sat outside his restaurant Pied àRead full story

Read full story

Retail Insider event with Andy Harding, CEO at NiX by Nicola Harding and MD at NH&Co.

Retail Insider held its latest event with guest speaker Andy Harding, CEO at NiX by Nicola Harding and MD at NH&Co., at Hedonism Wines in London’s Mayfair followed by a tutored tasting of wines. The event sponsored by BetterCommerce involved senior executives from Jigsaw, Ribble Cycles, Henderson Design Group, Heal’s and Stuart Trevor hearing AndyRead full story

Read full story