Sustainable Fashion: The future of eco-labelling

Brought to you by Retail Insider, Clipper Group and Give Back Box

Welcome to this column within our broader sustainability section which focuses on what fashion retailing is doing to address the issues in its industry.

This month’s column asks how environmental standards in fashion can best be communicated to consumers. Brought to you by Retail Insider with Clipper and Give Back Box.

Last month this column reported on Zalando’s calls for an industry wide set of environmental definitions to help ease consumers’ confusion. The fashion world undoubtedly faces an uphill battle trying to provide ethical information which is trustworthy, verifiable and independent especially in the face of consumer opinion that is often cynical and doubtful. But there are some glimmers of hope.

Ernst & Young’s recent survey ‘EY Future Consumer Index’ includes the usual and well-rehearsed consumer pledges to buy more sustainably sometime “in the future” that we are all now used to. Putting to one side for the moment the obvious point about our ‘survey self’, which acts a whole lot better than we actually do in real life, at least most of the people in this report (67%) were willing to admit that it is actually the higher relative cost that turns them towards cheaper clothing.

Products that have been sustainably produced will most likely always be more financially expensive than their counterparts which have used more water, not replenished trees felled in their production and have not properly paid the workers who made them and it is probably asking too much of manufacturers to produce clothing ethically and cheaply.

More worrying is the finding that 51% of the 1,000 shoppers who were surveyed did not trust either brands or retailers enough to make those sustainable choices while 56% said that misleading product information was actively putting them off buying ethically. For this cohort of respondees – even if they are the relatively small minority for whom cost is not the issue – sellers do have a responsibility to come up with a trusted and independent way of informing about the relative merits of clothing.

Sadly there are signs that the presentation of this evidence, which is going to be so important, is going down a piecemeal route whereby single retailers are developing their own systems. For completely understandable reasons brands and retailers are tired of waiting for the whole industry to agree on a set of standards and ways of communicating them and they are choosing to go it alone.

An example of the Provenance authentication on Cult Beauty

Some retailers including Cult Beauty have been working with Provenance – a small but fast growing company that uses blockchain technology to enable all the ethical data points on a product to be securely embedded behind the listing on the retailer’s website. When users click on it they can view – via the Provenance interface – the third-party verification of all that information so they no longer have to take the retailers’ word for it that the factory, for example, was run on ethical lines.

Alternatively there is also the Higg Index model favoured by the Sustainable Apparel Coalition (SAC), which includes some of the biggest fashion retailers in its membership of 250. SAC member H&M is starting a trial using eco-labels that benchmark a small selection of its clothes with grades from one to three depending on the material used.

Critical will be the independence of the information given – and possibly a hybrid model that uses the Provenance blockchain verifications embedded in a SAC label would be a useful joint-venture. If the take-up of the H&M pilot is positive it could turn on a big green light for other retailers in the consortium.

As has often been pointed out the traffic light labelling on food is a very blunt instrument but its great strength is that everyone understands it. The Holy Grail for retailers is a similarly easy-to-use benchmarked label with blockchain verifications behind it for customers to scan. This would lay to rest once and for all the argument that distrust and poor information is the reason why people do not buy sustainably. It’s time for the sellers to call the buyers’ bluff.

Supported by:


Read More »

Opportunity for retailers to address personalisation shortcomings

Personalisation has very much been under the spotlight during Covid-19 as shoppers have gravitated to online channels and expected an experience that mimics the one enjoyed in-store but it has all too frequently been found wanting. Phil Bacon, senior ERP consultant at Xpedition, says: “Lots of businesses will now be looking at themselves coming throughRead full story

Read full story

Entrepreneurial bravery required…

Sitting in the grounds of Grantley Hall near Ripon in North Yorkshire enjoying a coffee there is much to distract the eye including the pristine acres of grass adorned with flowers and manicured shrubbery, the bubbling River Skell, and the imposing Grade II-listed Hall itself. But what was most noticeable was the array of employeesRead full story

Read full story

The importance of product selection…

When Tesco introduced its first small format convenience stores some years back, it pinpointed the 100 key items it needed to always have in stock at each of these outlets. The list was an odd mix including the likes of Steradent denture tablets and Carlsberg Special Brew. The criteria was based on them being premium-pricedRead full story

Read full story

Innovative Retailer: Cuyana

The Name: Cuyana The Place: Well, lots of shops obviously. But this particular one iscurrently on an automobile trip round America. The Story: Have you ever wanted to be a rock star and shout “Hello Florida!!” from the front of a huge stage? No: I see. How about “If it’s Tuesday it must be CulverRead full story

Read full story

Indie retailers continue to appraise their business models

Small independent brands like Copperhouse Chocolate are attaching less value to their physical units having focused on other areas of revenue generation during Covid-19 and the various lockdowns. From a unit on Islington’s Chapel Market in North London Copperhouse Chocolate operates a cafe in the front end and has production facilities in the back whereRead full story

Read full story

Much greater focus needed on reusing goods…

Greater focus must be placed on reusing unwanted electrical goods rather than on recycling within the UK, which lags behind the rest of Europe partly as a result of the ongoing stigma attached to buying second-hand goods. Cris Stephenson, CEO of Environcom – the UK’s leading independent recycler of e-waste and provider of reuse, saysRead full story

Read full story

Creating buzz through limited edition releases

Visiting the Tillingham Winery in the rolling countryside on the edge of the East Sussex town of Rye was not only a relief to be out of stuffy London on what was a gloriously hot day but it also gave some insights into what hospitality businesses might well need to embrace in the post-covid-19 world.Read full story

Read full story

The right stance

Visiting St John restaurant in the Clerkenwell area of London for the first time in about 15 years was an enjoyable experience, partly because of the familiarity I felt even though I can hardly call myself a regular. From my recollection, very little seemed to have changed over the intervening years apart from the factRead full story

Read full story

Movers & Shakers Q&A with Simon Leesley, MD at Stitch Fix UK

Simon Leesley, MD, Stitch Fix UK 1. What is the greatest opportunity for your business? Stitch Fix is able to offer personalisation at scale, which given recent moves in consumer behaviour, habits and expectations due to the pandemic, is more important than ever. The seismic consumer shift from offline to online shopping presents an importantRead full story

Read full story